How to Perform Candle Testing

Candle testing prior can avoid a lot of troubleshooting later on. Make this part of your candle-making process. Learning what candle performs better will help you get the most from this craft.

To perform candle testing properly you make candles that represent what you would be selling. The test candle is made using the jar, wick, and fragrance that is selected for use. The wick is monitored for burn performance and documented to validate that the wick will adequately deliver the fuel needed to produce a proper melt pool. The melt pool vapor will be a means for evaluating the hot throw from the candle.

Always practice good safety first. While it is not the law, you would not do well in a court of law without evidence that you did everything you could to make a safe product. Your candle-making business relies on word of mouth reputation and repeated business. Testing your candles’ performance is how you can measure your customer’s satisfaction. Not everyone will give you feedback and if they do it is usually negative or an angry customer.

This post contains some affiliate links for your convenience, read our full earnings disclaimer.

Candle making is a special process. You do not know the quality of the product until after it is made. Verifying the quality requires burning the candle and it is no longer suitable for sale. These are the candles I keep for myself. If need be I repair or rework them.

I NEVER SELL CANDLES THAT HAVE PARTICIPATED IN TESTING. I once re-used a glass jar and did not realize that the stress from the heat caused small fractures. On the second use, the glass broke spilling wax everywhere.

Initial Candle Testing

All combinations of containers, wicks, waxes, colorant, additive, and fragrance oil should be tested as well as manufacturing processes. If you are a beginner, start with 4 to six fragrances and choose 1 style of a container in 1 size. Take this one step at a time. When buying supplies, buy from a candle supply company so that you get support.

They know their products and can help you match up what you are buying. This way you start with something close and are not going in circles. If you buy a starter kit, the testing phase should be done for you.

If you change containers, you have to perform another test. If you change fragrance oils, you have to test. If you change the fragrance load from 8% to 10%, you have to test. You have to test all of the candle combinations. If you change suppliers, you have to test.

Manufacturing Candle Testing

Once you are in production, determine a sample size that you are comfortable with. Let me clarify this. You should be pulling a candle from your product line at least 1 in 100 candles you make and perform a candle burn test. You should vary your choice so that you are spot-checking your results. You should be documenting this in your log. If you are a candle lover, and probably are, document your burning. Label it. Take a picture.

Inspection Records for Candle Making

On my resource page, there is a printable pdf for a label and a log for candle testing. If you cannot make stickers, tape the label on. You should record your findings on the log and keep these records. This is proof that you know how your candle performing. This testing phase can give you a guide for each time you make candles. From this, you would develop your recipes.  Before you can test candles you have to make some candles.

Making Test Candles

Test candles are of no value if they do not represent what you plan to manufacture and sell. To get started you only need to make 1 version of the candle and let it cure for 3 to 4 days. You can make a sorter candle as to not waste as much product. If you plan on heating the wax on a double boiler system and pouring from a metal pitcher that is a manufacturing process.

If you switch to a presto pot or use a larger melting pot you have changed your manufacturing process and need to spot test. Not much usually changes, but I had an issue controlling the cooling temperature when I went to larger batches and had issues with cratering.

  1. Make a candle as you normally would and let cure.
  2. Before lighting smell the candle and not the cold throw.
  3. Label the candle with the date, start time, wax type, wick, and fragrance oil. Log the information.
  4. Place the candle inside another container (I use an old cake pan), do not leave the candle unattended, and burn for 1 hour.
  5. Check the candle and make notes of the flame size, soot if any, wax pool, smell, etc. After 1 hour the candle should just be getting started with a shallow melt pool.
  6. Check the candle again after 2 hours. Check again as in step 4. Look to see if the wick has a mushroom or if it has self-extinguished. The melt pool should be less than ½” deep and should reach the edges of the candle vessel.
  7. Check under the candle to make sure the candle is not so hot it is burning any surface. The container will be hot to the touch but should not look burned.
  8. Take note of the hot throw in the room. Can you smell the fragrance around the candle?
  9. Check the candle again after 4 hours as above. The melt pool should be around ½” with a moderate flame and no mushrooming. The outer edges should not look burned.
  10. Gently blow the candle out. Make note of any tunneling or the appearance of the wax after it has cooled.

Candle Inspection Results

Small Flame,                                       Wick too small

Large Flame,                                       Wick too big

Flame Flares,                                       Air trapped, pour hotter

Wick Burns Out,                                 Wick too small or too much fragrance oil or wick clogged

Flame Sputters,                                   Water in Wax or wick clogged

Melt pool to shallow,                          Wick too small

Melt pool deep,                                    Wick too large

Wick smokes,                                        Wick too large or room drafty

Wick tunnels,                                         Wick too small

Wax has craters,                                    Air pockets or poured to cool

Sinkholes around Wick,                       Poured too hot

No smell before lit,                                Not enough fragrance oil

No smell in room,                                  Wick too small or not enough fragrance oil

Top of the candle oily,                           Too much fragrance oil or not cured

The flame still seems too high,            Try a different style wick, HTP vs CD

Candle Manufacturing Testing and Inspection

Make a suitable candle. Most of the manufacturing process for candles is common sense but sometimes that thought does not come to us until a mishap or someone points it out. We all know that a candle should never be left unattended but we get busy and forget about things. We have to assume that our customers have good intentions and can get distracted or simply do not follow instructions. We work with candles as part of our daily lives and experience more than they ever would. We need to keep this in mind when making candles.

As a practice, I make small to moderate size candles. I am careful to not make candles that burn deep into a container. This avoids overheating as the burn time is limited. A deep candle inside a glass jar gets very hot on top and has a greater risk of breaking. Taller candles are also top-heavy and are a greater risk of falling over. It is our job to reduce the risks of fire or injury as best we can and verify that as we continue to manufacture.

Purchasing from reputable candle supply sources and inspecting supplies. My primary candle vessel is a jelly jar a half pint and a pint jar made by Ball Corporation. This is what I carry for inventory 90% of the time. I also buy the glass jars without lids from Dollar Tree. I use these when I want to make holiday candles or specialty candles. Very rarely do I use a different container.

Pick glass containers that are heavy and suitable for heat. Containers can reach up to about 150 degrees. If a container is marked on the bottom as not safe for microwave or not dishwasher safe, stay clear! I have used wine glasses. I made sure to go as small as I could with the wick size as to not overheat the glass.

Before using any containers, check for fractures, cracks, splits, or chips that could propagate into a crack. If you are using tins, make sure seams are sealed or buy seamless tins.

Check your wicks to make sure they are secure to the tab.

Check your wax bags, boxes, and your fragrance oils to damage to the containers. Store in a dry secure location away from heat and open flames. Keep the lids on when not accessing the products.

All products should be identified including where they came from and when they were purchased. Keep a receiving log including the cost for accounting. I give everything a batch number and reference this later when making candles.

Candle Manufacturing Process

Before I make candles, I assign an assembly batch number and document the containers, wicks, wax, and fragrance batches I used. This batch number could be put on the label. Currently, I do not, but maybe I should. In the event something went wrong I would be able to trace back to what I used for that candle. You would rarely need to but you never know.

Verify that the glue you are using is not prone to coming loose. The wick should stay firmly in place while your candle is cooling. I have found that wick sticks can come loose. Check your candles for wick stability.

If this is a problem, switch to hot glue or glue such as an RTV or E6000 craft glue. After your candles have cooled, check each one to make sure the wick is still centered. Do not use candles that have a wick off to the side. The container will become too hot and may break.

Clean the containers for any drips and recheck the glass for cracks or chips. Handling may have damaged a jar.

Trim the wicks to about ¼” and inspect the tops of the wax. If there are slight imperfections smooth with a heat tool.

Check the overall appearance of the candle, document your findings and it is ready to be labeled. Congratulations!

Candle Testing Tips

Sometimes we want to use unconventional containers or not listed or we are just not sure for whatever reason. What you can do to save on the wax and save some time is to make the initial candle with a place holder like a wick pin. You can also hold the initial wick in place without the wick tab. If the wick is too small or too big when it cools you can pull the wick out and push another in its place. When you have found a wick that is closer to what you think it should be go ahead and perform your regular test.

It is still important to burn the test candle for 4 hours as it should be manufactured. This will help speed up your testing if you need a more reasonable starting point.

Troubleshooting for Candle Testing

If you are struggling to get a good hot throw from your candle, there are some things you can do.

Start from the beginning and make your candle without any coloring. Sometimes additives interfere with the performance of the wick. A common misconception is using colorants that are not meant for candles such as micas. They are pretty, but they clog the wick and do not allow the melt pool to flow through the wick and cast an aroma.

Additionally, finding a wick that works well with the specific blend of wax you are using in the specific container diameter is often a challenge. Some wicks work better than others in different scenarios and just finding a starting point is confusing. Below is a starter guide with various wicks to show you how they compare. The bigger the number the bigger the wick. The bigger the container diameter the bigger the wick needs to be. How tall or deep the container is doesn’t matter.

Candle Vessel Wick Starter-Guide
Some wicks work better in soy and some better in paraffin. This is just a starting point.
This is for container and pillar. All candles need testing.
Vessel Diameter
mm inches Zinc Core HTP CDN CD ECO LX
36 1.42 1 8
38 1.50 2 8
39 1.54 2 8
40 1.57 13 3 2 10
42 1.65 31 3 2 10
43 1.69 41 4 2 10
44 1.73 52 4 2 10
45 1.77 62 5 4 2 10
46 1.81 44-24-18 62 5 5 2 10
47 1.85 44-24-18 72 5 5 2 10
49 1.93 44-24-18 73 6 5 2 10
50 1.97 44-24-18 73 7 5 2 10
52 2.05 44-24-18 83 8 6 4 12
55 2.17 44-24-18 83 8 6 4 12
56 2.20 44-24-18 93 8 6 4 12
59 2.32 44-24-18 104 10 7 4 14
63 2.48 44-24-18 104 12 7 6 14
66 2.60 44-24-18 104 14 8 6 16
68 2.68 44-24-18 104 16 8 6 16
71 2.80 51-32-18 105 18 8 8 16
73 2.87 51-32-18 105 18 8 8 16
75 2.95 51-32-18 105 20 8 10 16
78 3.07 51-32-18 126 20 10 10 18
80 3.15 51-32-18 136 22 10 10 18
82 3.23 51-32-18 1212 24 12 12 20
89 3.50 60-44-18 1212 26 14 14 20
95 3.75 60-44-18 1212 28 16 14 21
102 4.00 60-44-18 1212 30 18 22
108 4.25 60-44-18 1312 20 24
114 4.50 60-44-18 XL 100 22 26
121 4.75 XL 100 22 28
127 5.00 30